Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Wow, this is exactly how not to design.

Separating layout and content is a mistake. Content should be inextricably linked to how it is presented. This is what design means; it means taking content and displaying it in an understandable and pleasing way. Every piece of content desires to be presented differently.

This is exactly why CSS is such a horrible pile crap. It trains designers to separate content from presentation, and it's not designed for page layout. CSS is designed for forcing content into little boxes.

As long as people design for the web by separating content from presentation, we're never going to evolve into something better.

Just look at the end result of this article. It's a boring, lifeless "design" as a container for any type of content. It goes completely counter the very soul of Zeldman's quotation.



And here you have described the difference between print design and web design. They each have constraints.


"Better" was the web before there was CSS. Black background, white text. Links. That was all anyone needed.

Now the web is the equivalent of a coffee-table book. Glossy and colorful, but expensive and lacking any substantial content.


I can only hope you're joking. Design, by itself, is pointless; content, by itself, is the point.


Badly-presented content can be useless or misleading. Good design may not draw attention to itself when you're paying attention to the content, but it's still there. e.g. http://graysuite.blogspot.com/2009/06/consider-my-mind-blown...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: