Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> the interviewer is always right

That is an awful sentiment, and I find myself in violent disagreement with you.

A good number of my enjoyable interviews have been with candidates who clearly knew more than I did, and could expand from an interesting detail to a short ex-tempore lecture on the topic. I cherish each of those.

An interview where I, as an interviewer, learn something is a fine thing indeed.



If the interviewer is in a position where he/she seems willing to listen and learn, then by all means impress. However, correcting an interviewer is always a dangerous gamble, and it is downright foolish to keep arguing with him or her when he/she doesn't agree with you.


> That is an awful sentiment, and I find myself in violent disagreement with you.

You find yourself in violent insistence that the world is the way you wish it was, rather than the way it actually is.


In that case I am shaping the world around me.

Any company who maintains that their interviewers are always right is telegraphing that they treat their workforce as mindless cogs in a machine.

Every time I encounter a candidate who thinks differently than I do, I treat him or her as a potential source of inspiration. Occasionally I learn something, and occasionally they do.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: