At the risk of starting a mini-flame war, is RST a more cohesive format? If one was to pick one of the two formats to start using for personal documentation, which format should one choose?
I do think rST is waaay more expressive, but I also recognize that in many of the instances one would want to use markup in a chat or PR situation, the expressiveness likely wouldn't be well received if the trade-off is verbosity.
This is something in life that I file away with competing regex standards: my brain just has to switch languages based on the app in which I'm typing (between markdown, pseudo-markdown (ahem, Slack), org-mode, rST, etc).
For personal documentation (assuming you mean notes): follow your heart. Personally, though, I wouldn't use RST for any non-python public documentation at this point, but for my personal notes, it's hard to beat the extensibility of RST.