Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Tons of reasons. For one, I wrote "native" above, and the web+JS aint that.

But even if we ask the more general question, why "web+js can't be the great cross platform toolkit", the answer IMHO is:

Web+JS are and will always be (due to the nature of the platform) inherently slower than optimal (even if "fast enough" for simple apps), use more memory, use more CPU, don't use the native facilities and so are foreign to every OS look and feel (from themes to usability features), and so on. And of course they're "bring your own theme" affairs, so no standard users can get used to, everybody does their own BS UI in SPAs and web-engine based apps (like Spotify and Atom).

Add the amateur hour development practices that they enable (where a company that would previously hire actual GUI programmers can now hire some web devs and let them loose to create its app) and the picture is not nice...



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: