Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Our bodies are composed of information too.

LOL basically you have to accept that our current scientific understanding is that our minds are embodied constructs (your mind doesn’t exist in any meaningful way without your brain, which is a physical organ and fundamentally and essentially integrated with the body).

Thought itself is embodied.

Your argument proves the necessity of physical contact for human health.

Our biologies - our brains and bodies - require the information (chemical impulses, electrical impulses, etc) provided by our senses when embodied physical touch, sight, sound, the body heat of another person, etc, occur.

Unless a perfect simulacra of physical human interaction (including the ability for us to move our own physical bodies) was created, there will always be a lack of the information (consider the chemicals released by exercise, by a hug, and impact of said chemicals on the brain, the combination of chemicals from eating with the chemicals of being close to someone you like) which our embodied minds require for health.

You’d have to put a brain in a vat and feed it every single electrical impulse and chemical it would normally receive from being part of the body.

Otherwise you lose information and god knows what happens.

I don’t deny the value of interaction via the Internet, etc.

To imply it is anywhere near replacing the information density of embodied physical contact is just a sign of a lack of information - education - about all this stuff.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: