Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I also don't like that Signal relies on phone numbers or a QR code from a phone to log in. Phone numbers are traceable to identities. They really should have used usernames or e-mail addresses.

Also, Signal's desktop app shouldn't require a stupid phone app to enable it. I have a big powerful setup on my desk and you're asking me to go around my house looking for a silly 6" device to give it permission to log in? That's backwards. It should be the other way around if anything.



And leaking a mail (with real names) is much better?


Yes. Phone numbers are linked to a physical device (a SIM card or similar) or a contract (with a provider). An email does not need to contain a real name, and I'd say it's much easier for me to get a email with a temporary identity than it is to get a phone number for the same.


Not only that, but many countries have regulation that requires providing some form of government ID to obtain a phone number, even a virtual one.


E-mail doesn't have to have real names, isn't regulated by the government, and the same ID can be used across the world.


It takes 5 minutes to set up a new email account just for this app if you want to do so...


Yes, because you can choose if you want your name in your address.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: