Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I don't disagree with the smartphones and WiFi, though the big 2 are highly motivated to at least secure the kernel and their own spyware. I am more thinking of these things targeting sensitive military installations or personnel.

> whether or not we can make our rulers live under the same panopticon as the rest of us.

Uh, nope. It's been "rules for thee and not for me" since the dawn of time.



> I am more thinking of these things targeting sensitive military installations or personnel.

Ah, yes, it sure would be nice to think that they're a bit more careful, but then I think of things like the OPM leak and I go cross-eyed. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Office_of_Personnel_Management... - I'm sure you know what I'm talking about but I figured I'd add a link for anyone who didn't.)

> It's been "rules for thee and not for me" since the dawn of time.

Aye, but I think that's just what the panopticon could overturn, if we set it up that way. I'm not particularly hopeful, but maybe there's a possible future where we overcome our worser natures and use technology wisely. Star Trek vs. N. Korea.

FWIW I call this idea the "Tyranny of Mrs. Grundy": if everyone is on the lens-end of the cameras, including police and politicians, then no one escapes censure by Mrs. Grundy. ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mrs_Grundy ) We're forced to create a "humane tyranny".

"Humane tyranny" sounds like an oxymoron from today's POV, but I think the challenge is to "de-oxymoron-icize" it. Due to the advancing tech, I don't think it's optional , the panopticon will happen (it arguably already has), so the challenge is to make it more-or-less livable.


I want to be hopeful about the future, but in the large there are too many negative trends. What I've learned is to be hopeful and optimistic about the things I can change. Just about to go watch an episode of TNG. Here's hoping that the long run is better than our current trajectory. Cheers!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: