Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Has anyone here experimented with IPFS to create a mirrored video archive for things like their YouTube channels?

I don't hear much about IPFS these days.



I have - I've used IPFS to archive the channel of a creator I like (in true data-hoarding fashion).

It is neither convenient nor especially easy. It's mostly managed by a home-grown bash script that uses yt-dlp to archive videos, organized by playlist, and then update a IPNS key.

I plan on writing up a blog post about it at some point, if there's interest. I mentioned the project to the particular creator's fan discord (the creator doesn't participate with the community at all themselves) and there was a surprising amount of backlash from the community leaders. Most of the concerns revolved around the notion that I was somehow stealing ad revenue from the creator (despite my explanations that IPFS is not at all a convenient platform for video consumption). I might take the IPFS node off of the public network to circumvent this worry, and only peer with other parties interested in archival of that specific channel.


IPFS still has poor performance for very little innovation. Bittorrent still works perfectly fine, and in fact peertube uses webtorrent to distribute content from browser to browser to offload the server. It is perfectly possible to mirror peertube channels on bittorrent


IPFS got their fat investment check and got to work on their own crypto-currency (filecoin). I kinda feel like the project lost its way.


The incentives are aligned towards token value and investment growth instead of technology development, inside the sausage factory.

I hope they get back to making useful software soon, but I'm not holding my breath.

At least it's all open source.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: