Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think you got this quite wrong.

> Has open source software ended up as a "larger and blander" sea of software "retellings" compared to proprietary software?

By all means, yes! There are so many open source clones of proprietary software, lots of stuff that is solved, but fun to rewrite, so people do it. How many pointless gnome themes are there? How many web servers, media players, databases?

That’s survivor bias. The number of bland, irrelevant forks on GitHub far outnumbers the few relevant projects, it’s just that we, as software developers, have found ways to ignore those as we sift through options.



It’s survivor bias in the same way humans have survived all of the various failed experiments of evolution.

I think it’s a question of progress vs profit. Though, I also think there needs to be a reasonably balance between the two.


So the system adapted and we are all better of due to that. That warrants the question why we should expect anything else with copyright?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: