Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> reading about meditation is never going to get you a full understanding

Right. And do you really even need a whole book to explain how to do meditation?

Can it not be explained in one paragraph?

Is it even as complicated as a recipe in a cookbook with many steps and ingredients?

How many steps and subtasks and ingredients are there to do meditation?

Now I would be interested in seeing a book that explains some rational as to why a given meditation technique does some good to you. I believe it does, but don't know why. Therefore could it be like placebo?



I would argue that, yes, you do in fact need either a book or a teacher. Meditation practices and traditions didn't spontaneously develop in a vacuum, they were created in the context of spiritual traditions such as Buddhism. Non-attachment and no-self are very difficult concepts, but they are the aim of meditation! Without a good teacher (or at least, a good book), meditation can lead to some dark places.

Edit: Of course you are correct that the actual technique is very simple and can be explained in a few sentences. But there is much more to it than that - how do you process the results? That's what you need a book/teacher/help for.


You sound like somebody who has not spent a lot of time meditating. Maybe try it before opining further?

You need many books to explain how to do meditation, because people vary widely and it's a complex set of skills with subtle goals. However, reading a thousand books is not sufficient to understand it, any more than reading all the books about bicycles can make you able to ride a bike.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: