Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's really funny to watch a bunch of people contradict the US Navy when it comes to navigation at sea. No, a cell phone isn't going to work in the middle of the Pacific and no, the US Navy doesn't use Google maps. Go get on an actual boat sometime and sail out of sight of land, you lose cell signal way before you're even over the horizon.


A cellphone's GPS only relies on the network for a quickstart. With no network, it takes longer to get the initial fix, but then works perfectly fine.


> A cellphone's GPS only relies on the network for a quickstart.

The point is not to rely on GPS/GNSS:

* https://gpsjam.org


Not always true. I have devices with GPS which not only relies on a network for getting ephemeris data for the satellites, but they can't function without it. In other words, they don't even try to get ephemeris data through the GPS signal. So, if there's no network, it doesn't work. One of my devices is even a tablet without a SIM card, it only has wifi.. so if I'm near a cafeteria with wifi I can get a fix, and keep it for a while, but without it it's totally stuck. Forever.

In any case, as others have said, in the ocean a cellphone is useless for navigation. At least use a standalone satellite navigator. And learn to use paper maps and a sextant, it's actually a lot of fun.


Ships do use GPS and so do phones and other devices. What exactly are you trying to say?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: