The analogy is pretty generous towards LLMs. I like Eevee's response to it in her blog post[1]:
>What I do know is that a table saw quickly cuts straight lines. That is the thing it does. It doesn’t do Whatever. It doesn’t sometimes cut wavy lines and sometimes glue pieces together instead. It doesn’t roll some dice and guess what shape of cut you are statistically likely to want based on an extensive database of previous cuts. It cuts a straight f*cking line.
>If I were a carpenter, and my colleagues got really into this new thing where you just chuck 2×4s at a spinning whirling mass of blades until a chair comes out the other side… you know, I just might want to switch careers.
If the original framing was too generous, the response is at least as ungenerous. Table saws aren't deterministic tools either, and anyone who has used one for more than a minute can tell you that getting it to consistently cut the straight line you want takes skill.
>What I do know is that a table saw quickly cuts straight lines. That is the thing it does. It doesn’t do Whatever. It doesn’t sometimes cut wavy lines and sometimes glue pieces together instead. It doesn’t roll some dice and guess what shape of cut you are statistically likely to want based on an extensive database of previous cuts. It cuts a straight f*cking line.
>If I were a carpenter, and my colleagues got really into this new thing where you just chuck 2×4s at a spinning whirling mass of blades until a chair comes out the other side… you know, I just might want to switch careers.
[1]: https://eev.ee/blog/2025/07/03/the-rise-of-whatever/