Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I have experienced this issue some time too - I think if you post some "controversial" comment (judged by many quick upvotes and downvotes) it triggers a "cooling down" period before you can post a reply to your immediate child comments in the thread (or it could be mod-triggered). This ensures you don't dominate the thread, and allows a conversation with other participants to develop. Based on how others react to the comments, I assume it also gives the mods a better idea if they need to intervene. I found it a minor annoyance at first, but have learnt to appreciate it - thoughtful comments (with careful moderation) from a diverse group of people is what makes a community like this valuable.
 help



Seems dangerously close to the way reddit went down by silencing anyone with controversial opinions.

Ehn, HN has always been strongly moderated.

I've gotten into plenty of flamewars with Dems, Republicans, Anti-Vaxxers, Pro-Vaxxers, AI Luddites, AI Fundamentalists, China bots, China hawks, Apple fanatics, Apple haters, far-right, far-left, pro-WFH, anti-WFH, pro-immigration, anti-immigration, and others on HN.

I just don't care about filtering my opinions and use HN as a way to kvetch and impart some information I may know about.


At least all this different viewpoints are here, so maybe the difference is if the moderation is ideologically motivated or not.

I'm not quite sure.

I and a couple other long-time HN users have noticed a significant degradation in HN after a persistent boom in sign-ups began around 2022-23.

It's hard to answer lol.


I also think that the quality declined with the incoming AI crowd but on the other hand I also got older over the last years and increased my own skill level...



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: